Earl of Sandwich Makes a Comeback: Now Serving at Fast Eddy’s on Chinden

If you’ve been missing your favorite hot sandwich fix, you’re not alone. When Earl of Sandwich quietly closed its Treasure Valley locations earlier this year, it left local fans wondering if they’d ever get their hands on those signature melts again.

Good news: Earl of Sandwich is officially back, this time in an unexpected spot.

The iconic sandwich shop has set up inside the brand-new Fast Eddy’s on Chinden Boulevard, bringing its beloved menu to a new kind of customer experience.

Let’s take a look at what this means for Boise’s sandwich lovers and why this comeback is a little different from what you might expect.

A Fresh Take on a Fan Favorite

Earl of Sandwich isn’t new to the Treasure Valley. Known for their hot, freshly baked sandwiches, the chain built a loyal following with items like the Tuna Melt, the classic Roast Beef & Horseradish, and their tangy Hawaiian BBQ.

But earlier this year, local locations quietly closed, leaving a sandwich-shaped hole in the hearts (and lunch plans) of many.

Now, the brand is making a return but with a twist. Rather than reopening a standalone restaurant, Earl of Sandwich is now the featured dining spot inside the brand-new Fast Eddy’s flagship location on Chinden Boulevard in Boise.

What’s Inside the New Fast Eddy’s?

This isn’t your typical gas station stop.

The new Fast Eddy’s on Chinden is more than a place to fuel up. It’s a 10,000+ square-foot convenience experience designed to combine everyday essentials with premium offerings.

Here’s what you’ll find under one roof:

• Chevron Gas Station – Modern pumps with plenty of space for easy in-and-out access

• Full-Service Car Wash – Keeping your ride looking sharp while you grab a snack or sandwich

• Earl of Sandwich Restaurant – Serving up all your breakfast and lunch favorites from the signature menu

• Expanded Retail Area – Snacks, drinks, and convenience items beyond your typical gas station selection

It’s part of a growing trend where convenience stores double as food destinations, offering locals a quick stop that doesn’t compromise on quality.

Why This Move Makes Sense

On the surface, it might seem odd to find a beloved sandwich shop tucked inside a gas station. But this kind of pairing is becoming more common, and it’s actually a smart move for both brands.

For Fast Eddy’s, adding a recognizable food brand helps drive traffic beyond just gas and snacks. For the Earl of Sandwich, it’s a chance to reintroduce its menu to the community without the overhead of a traditional standalone location.

Plus, with Chinden Boulevard’s busy corridor seeing steady growth, this new hybrid model puts them right in the path of thousands of daily commuters.

What You Can Expect on the Menu

The full Earl of Sandwich experience is back, including customer favorites like:

• The Tuna Melt – Creamy, savory, and always a classic

• Roast Beef & Horseradish – A bold flavor combo with just the right kick

• Hawaiian BBQ – A sweet and smoky sandwich with a tropical twist

• Breakfast Options – Because great sandwiches aren’t just for lunch

Whether you’re stopping for a quick breakfast before work or grabbing lunch on the go, this new spot aims to deliver quality and convenience in one stop.

What This Means for Local Food Fans

Boise’s food scene has been growing and evolving, with new concepts, fusion spots, and big-name chains all staking their claim.

Earl of Sandwich’s return, especially in this hybrid format, shows how brands are adapting to fit the Treasure Valley’s changing landscape. With growth corridors like Chinden seeing more traffic and development, businesses are looking for creative ways to connect with the community.

This also points to a larger trend: blending fast-casual dining with everyday convenience.

The Bottom Line: Worth a Stop?

If you’ve been craving a hot sandwich with fresh ingredients and bold flavors, the new Earl of Sandwich inside Fast Eddy’s might be just the right mix of comfort food and convenience.

It’s an easy stop for locals, commuters, or anyone curious to see how the Treasure Valley’s dining and convenience scene continues to evolve.

Stay in the Know on Local Food, Growth, and Community News

Whether it’s a favorite sandwich shop making a comeback, a new development reshaping a neighborhood, or a behind-the-scenes look at Treasure Valley growth, we’re here to keep you informed.

Follow @iHeartCityOfTrees for updates on local news, business highlights, and community happenings delivered in plain English, without the fluff.